Garth Coates Solicitors Limited, authorised and regulated by the SRA (No. 838255)Authorised and regulated by the SRA (No. 838255)

  1. Home
  2. Guides and articles
  3. A new Independent Immigration Appeals Authority (IIAA) is proposed: what it means

A new Independent Immigration Appeals Authority (IIAA) is proposed: what it means

The Immigration and Asylum Bill would create a new body, the Independent Immigration Appeals Authority, to decide immigration and asylum appeals. This guide explains what it would do and the concerns for genuine applicants.

By Tamer Ulay 5 minute read
An elevated, slightly hazy daytime aerial view of the Palace of Westminster with the clock tower of Big Ben rising beside the River Thames, Westminste

In brief

  • The Immigration and Asylum Bill would create a new body, the Independent Immigration Appeals Authority (IIAA), to decide many immigration and asylum appeals.
  • The Commons passed the Bill at third reading on 17 November 2026 by 290 votes to 94. It now goes to the House of Lords and is not yet law.
  • The IIAA would use adjudicators who do not need to be legally qualified, rather than judges, and would eventually replace the First-tier Tribunal.
  • Critics are concerned about legal expertise, independence, limits on court challenge and the treatment of late claims.
  • Existing appeal rights and deadlines are unchanged for now.

The core of the Bill: a new appeals body

The Immigration and Asylum Bill would create a new body called the Independent Immigration Appeals Authority (the IIAA). It would decide many immigration and asylum appeals. An appeal is a request for an independent body to review a Home Office refusal.

The Bill is in Part 1 and clause 1 sets up the IIAA. It is the lead measure, but not the only one. The House of Commons passed the Bill at third reading on 17 November 2026 by 290 votes to 94. It now goes to the House of Lords. It is not yet law and its wording may still change.

How appeals work today

Today, appeals are decided by judges in the First-tier Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber). The Government says this system cannot cope with demand. The Bill's explanatory notes say the appeals backlog grew from about 31,000 in March 2023 to about 152,000 in March 2026. They give an average wait of 61 weeks. Other official figures differ slightly, but they all show waits of well over a year.

What the IIAA would do

  • Which cases: appeals against Home Office decisions on protection (asylum) claims and human rights claims, and certain immigration bail applications. Appeals against deprivation of citizenship would also move to the IIAA.
  • Who decides: independent adjudicators rather than judges. The Home Secretary has said the body would be staffed by “independent adjudicators, not judges”. Adjudicators would not need to be legally qualified. A smaller group of senior adjudicators would need legal training.
  • Appointments: the Home Secretary would appoint the Chair and first Chief Executive. The Chief Executive would appoint the adjudicators. The Home Office expects the Chair to be in post by spring 2027.
  • Challenging a decision: the IIAA could reconsider its own decision once. A party could then appeal to the Upper Tribunal on a point of law, but only with permission.
  • Single route: people would have one appeal route and would have to raise all relevant matters at the start. People facing removal could be served a “claim notice” requiring them to put forward any immigration or modern slavery claim.
  • Late claims: in the version printed at committee stage, information raised late is treated as damaging the person’s credibility, and late evidence is treated in a similar way unless there is a good reason for the delay. The Home Secretary could also ask for an appeal to be expedited, meaning dealt with faster. Check the final wording, because amendments were considered on 17 November.

When would it start?

Nothing in the Bill is in force yet. The Bill allows the First-tier Tribunal to continue alongside the IIAA for a time, with regulations moving cases between them. Evidence given to MPs suggested that, at best, the IIAA might begin hearing some cases in the later part of 2027. The Home Office has not confirmed a start date.

The Government’s case

The Government says a wider recruitment pool would let the system respond faster to changing demand. It says that some people lodge appeals only to delay removal, although genuine appeals must still be heard fairly. Supporters of the Bill argue that faster decisions help genuine applicants too, because they spend less time waiting.

Concerns that have been raised

Lawyers’ organisations and refugee charities have criticised the plan. They have said:

  • Asylum and human rights law is complex. Adjudicators without legal training may be more likely to make errors of law. That could produce more onward appeals and move the backlog to the Upper Tribunal rather than remove it.
  • Because the Home Secretary appoints the leadership, there may be a risk of real or perceived bias.
  • Court challenge to some procedural decisions is limited.
  • The Government’s own impact assessment describes the overall impact as uncertain. It gives no estimate of the set-up cost. It also warns of recruitment difficulty and of pressure on the Upper Tribunal and legal aid.

Our view: the impact on genuine applicants

This section is the opinion of Garth Coates Solicitors.

We support shorter waiting times. A year or more in limbo is hard on genuine applicants and their families. But speed is only a benefit if decisions are right.

Our main concern is the late-claims rules. Genuine claims are sometimes raised late. The reasons can include trauma, a fear of disclosing sensitive facts, poor earlier advice or a change in circumstances. Treating late information as damaging credibility risks penalising people with real claims. The requirement to raise everything at the start is difficult for people who cannot afford representation. Immigration legal aid is already scarce.

We also believe that appeals involving asylum and human rights are best decided by legally qualified decision-makers. Adjudicators who are not legally qualified may find it harder to apply complex law. For a person whose safety or family life is at stake, an error may have grave consequences. If that happens, the only remedy may be an onward appeal that needs permission.

The Bill contains other measures, including changes to how Article 8 (the right to private and family life) is applied, reform of the modern slavery framework and a single protection status. They will need separate explanation once the final text is clearer.

What to do now

Nothing changes for current appeals. Existing rights of appeal continue under the present system. Do not delay a deadline because of the Bill. Our guides explain appeals and judicial review and human rights claims. We will update this article as the Bill moves through the House of Lords.

How Garth Coates Solicitors can help

Our London immigration solicitors advise on appeals, asylum-related matters and human rights claims. If you want to understand how the Bill may affect a planned or pending application, please request a consultation.

This article is general information and was correct on 18 November 2026. It is not legal advice on your circumstances; immigration rules and fees change often. For advice on your case, request a consultation.

★★★★★

Special thank you to Nataliya for helping and guiding me step by step to fulfill the requirements for the application from beginning until I got the visa. My case was quite complicated, however, Nataliya was helping me to give the solution to make it happen.

V P. Parent visa, September 2026, on Google
★★★★★

I had an excellent experience with Leqa,Tara and the team throughout my ILR application. They were incredibly professional, supportive and reassuring from start to finish.

Ghazaal M. ILR, August 2026, on Google
★★★★★

Right from the orientation call on Day 1 till receiving our visa approvals, we had a pleasant and professional experience. Not only were all our queries patiently addressed, but the applications itself were very professionally prepared and extremely thorough.

Abhinav G. Dependant visa, July 2026, on Google

Let’s find your way forward.

Tell us about your plans and we’ll help with the next step.

Our consultations and service fees are set out before any work starts. Open weekdays 09:30 to 17:00.

Visa cost calculator

Home Office fees and the health surcharge only. Our own fee is quoted separately.